![]() |
| Handel: Amadigi di Gaula – Tim Morgan, Hilary Cronin, Rowan Pierce – Buxton Worldwide Competition (Picture: Genevieve Girling) |
Handel: Amadigi di Gaula; Tim Morgan, Rowan Pierce, Hilary Cronin, James Corridor, director: Olivia Fuchs, the English Live performance, conductor: Erin Helyard; Buxton Worldwide Competition at Buxton Opera Home
Reviewed 20 July 2026
By turns playful and distracting, Olivia Fuchs’s manufacturing allowed a high-quality younger forged to develop sturdy performances combining enjoyment and engagement with technical bravura
Handel’s opera Amadigi di Gaula (1715) belongs to a small group of operas he wrote when he first got here to London and the precise type of his model of opera seria was not but fastened. Like its predecessor Teseo (1713), Amadigi relies on a French supply and there are tantalising hints that the unique plans for the opera included French components corresponding to dancing. [see my article on Handel’s experimental early London period.] As it’s, Amadigi has a freedom of type that makes it enticing to trendy administrators.
Olivia Fuchs has directed Handel’s Amadigi di Gaula for the Buxton Worldwide Competition at Buxton Opera Home. We caught the ultimate efficiency on 20 July 2026. Erin Helyard (creative director of Pinchgut Opera) carried out the English Live performance with Tim Morgan (changing Jake Ingbar) as Amadigi, Rowan Pierce as Oriana, Hilary Cronin as Melissa and James Corridor as Dardano. Designs had been by Eleanor Bull with lighting by Ben Pickersgill.
Each Cronin and Morgan have type with this opera. Tim Morgan sang the title function with English Touring Opera in 2021 (directed by James Conway, carried out by Jonathan Peter Kenny, see my evaluation), while Hilary Cronin sang Oriana in live performance with the English Live performance (carried out by Kristian Bezuidenhout, see my evaluation).
![]() |
| Handel: Amadigi di Gaula – James Corridor – Buxton Worldwide Competition (Picture: Genevieve Girling) |
The opera has a kind of ‘black field’ plots beloved of opera seria: the characters all confined to a single place. Right here, 4 individuals in a love tangle: Melissa loves Amadigi who loves Oriana as does Dardano, all sophisticated by Melissa’s energy as a sorceress. What elevates the opera is the extraordinary energy of the music for Melissa and Dardano, each of whom are dissatisfied in love.
Olivia Fuchs’s playful manufacturing reinvented the piece as a kind of Love Island actuality tv programme, Melissa’s Island with Melissa (Hilary Cronin) because the host and the opposite three characters as contestants. Quick video clips gave hints and there was substantial dumb present through the overture. However because the programme ebook gave the basic plot, viewers members needed to be fast on the uptake to align the opening dialogue with what was taking place on stage.The opera was lower (a operating time of two hours half-hour together with interval) and divided into two components with Half Two starting with Dardano’s aria ‘Pena tiranna io sento al core’. Dardano didn’t reappear as a ghost and James Corridor additionally sang the deus ex machina Orgando, right here the TV programme’s producer. Half One was on the set of Melissa’s Island while Half Two was backstage.
![]() |
| Handel: Amadigi di Gaula – Hilary Cronin – Buxton Worldwide Competition (Picture: Genevieve Girling) |
The issue with the idea was that in Half One, you by no means knew when emotion was performative, for the TV cameras, and when actual. Melissa’s intense aria in Act One when she lament’s Amadigi’s unfaithfulness was beautifully sung by Hilary Cronin, however was this actual or performative? The change of location for Half Two at the very least meant that James Corridor’s remaining aria was most positively not performative. The ending relied on Melissa’s energy over Amadigi and Oriana being associated to look and social media presence quite than being a matter of life and dying.
The manufacturing was additionally extraordinarily busy, with issues consistently taking place and only a few arias had been allowed to occur on their very own.
Tim Morgan sang with mild, elegant tone, his passagework fluid. His Amadigi was a naif, issues had been executed to him and the character by no means actually received the kind of bravura second that Handel would write for later heroes (the castrato Senesino, who created 18 roles for Handel, all the time insisted on at the very least one bravura heroic aria). It’s maybe important that we first noticed him hymning the night time, with Morgan doing so with great class of line.
For all that Oriana his the hero’s beloved, the important thing feminine function is Melissa. Right here, Hilary Cronin, carrying an alarming purple wig and glossy fitted silver trouser swimsuit, had a whale of a time because the manipulative tv host. She made her tragic Act One aria really matter, making us consider Melissa’s ache. Then in Half Two she went to items magnificently. Cronin’s voice has shocking heft and he or she introduced actual talent and vividness to Melissa’s music, performing with clear relish.
![]() |
| Handel: Amadigi di Gaula – Tim Morgan, Rowan Pierce – Buxton Worldwide Competition (Picture: Genevieve Girling) |
James Corridor attacked Dardano’s first two arias with great gusto. There was little doubt that this Dardano was an motion hero and Corridor clearly loved the sheer bravura of the function. It was a commanding efficiency that actually cried out for a extra sympathetic setting, topped by an account of ‘Pena tiranna’ that was musical, intense and bodily vivid. Corridor made his return as Orgando, a completely totally different character, make full sense.
As Oriana, Rowan Pierce was lumbered with a really horrible wig (presumably intentionally). She needed to start as complete airhead, however then develop actual feeling when Oriana sees Amadigi apparently lifeless. Because the opera progressed, Oriana’s emotions grew to become extra intense, although Olivia Fuchs leveraged this by making Oriana more and more reliant on alcohol. Pierce managed all this with aplomb, displaying exceptional vary allied to nice appeal.
Within the pit, the English Live performance had been on terrific type beneath Erin Helyard. We had some high-quality solo instrumental moments significantly the bassoon in Dardano’s remaining aria, and the trumpet duetting with Melissa in hers.
![]() |
| Handel: Amadigi di Gaula – James Corridor, Rowan Pierce, Tim Morgan, Hilary Cronin – Buxton Worldwide Competition (Picture: Genevieve Girling) |
The mixture of the very good singing and the orchestral contribution meant that regardless of the views on the manufacturing itself, musically this was a night of full enjoyment.
The weblog is free, however I would be delighted if you happen to had been to point out your appreciation by shopping for me a espresso.
Elsewhere on this weblog
- Greater than a live performance: Mozart’s La clemenza di Tito on the Buxton Competition brings out the work’s actual drama – opera evaluation
- Compelling music drama: Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde returns to Longborough Competition Opera with Peter Wedd & Catharine Woodward, conductor Anthony Negus – opera evaluation
- Conducting is a career of lifelong studying: Vasily Petrenko on nurturing expertise & broadening horizons – characteristic
- Model & enjoyment: John Wilson & Sinfonia of London deliver Cheltenham Music Competition to a detailed with a lightweight music programme culminating in Eric Coates’s rarity Cinderella – live performance evaluation
- Gutsy & vivid: Verdi’s La traviata at St Paul’s Opera imaginatively reinvents the work as parable of punk London – opera evaluation
- Giulio Cesare on the Grange: very good music performances compensate for David Alden’s scattershot strategy to Handel’s masterpiece – opera evaluation
- It is all in regards to the music: Opera Holland Park refrain & Metropolis of London Sinfonia on terrific type beneath Naomi Woo in celebratory Turandot – evaluation
- Concertos for pals: Colin Currie in Tansy Davies, Tamsin Waley-Cohen in Freya Waley-Cohen with BBC NOW at Aldeburgh Competition – evaluation
- Highly effective moments: Paul Wingfield directs Chelsea Opera Group in a powerful account of Mozart’s Idomeneo – opera evaluation
- Residence

,%20Hilary%20Cronin%20(Melissa)%20and%20Rowan%20Pierce%20(Oriana)%20Credit_%20Genevieve%20Girling%20(1).jpg)
%20Credit%20Genevieve%20Girling.jpg)

%20and%20Tim%20Morgan%20(Amadigi)%20Credit%20Genevieve%20Girling.jpg)
,%20Rowan%20Pierce%20(Oriana),%20Tim%20Morgan%20(Amadigi)%20and%20Hilary%20Cronin%20(Melissa)%20Credit_%20Genevieve%20Girling.jpg)