3.6 C
Wolfsburg
Sunday, November 22, 2026

Bieito’s Paris Siegfried can’t see Nothung, the ring or the wooden for the timber – Seen and Heard Worldwide


FranceFranceFrance Wagner, Siegfried: Soloists, Orchestre de l’Opéra nationwide de Paris / Pablo Heras-Casado (conductor). Opéra Bastille, Paris, 10.11.2026 efficiency (directed by Jérémie Cuvillier) livestreamed on 19.11.2026. (JPr)

Tamara Wilson (Brünnhilde) and Andreas Schager (Siegfried) © Herwig Prammer/OnP

These on-line did higher than ticket-holders for the Siegfried efficiency on nineteenth November on the Opéra Bastille who solely received a live performance efficiency as a result of some members of the Paris Opera supported a nationwide strike. Typically, when an opera or ballet is broadcast an earlier efficiency can be recorded in case one thing goes improper with the reside feed, so on-line the Ring cycle might proceed with Siegfried from 9 days earlier.

Is an answer to Calixto Bieito’s Konzept any nearer, I’m not too certain. After the specter of AI hovered over Das Rheingold (evaluation right here), Die Walküre (evaluation right here) didn’t appear to take this anyplace specifically. We left Brünnhilde in a white plastic-lined room and Wotan conjuring up an orangey-red fog. A little analysis means that for Bieito this was chemical poison and, as we are going to quickly see in Act III, Brünnhilde is entombed in ice (neither is obvious from how Walküre ends). Now within the post-apocalypse, post-nuclear world of Siegfried, whereas the constructing from Walküre is already instructed initially within the distance, nature is out-of-control and a darkish, dense, lush forest with a grassy ground is taking on, even whether it is topsy-turvy with fir treetops coming in from the edges or down from above. It’s typically all proven flickering and increasing and with an intensive root system. A number of faceless figures roam – typically staggering or writhing as if sick – via the scenes who’re both mutant androids or mutant people from a nuclear disaster.

There isn’t a forging after all and neither is Mime the character he was in Rheingold, he now has hair, purple nail polish, glasses and a brown swimsuit with a medal. His life is in a steel suitcase; with blood stress monitor and the medication he’s depending on and makes an attempt to pressure on Siegfried who spits them out. Siegfried (in white shirt, soiled vest and darkish slacks) doesn’t usher in a bear, solely a battered automobile door that he proceeds to play with. Because the story unfolds we are going to see how he appears to need to sniff the whole lot! Mime’s supposed sword he has labored on is only a little bit of piping. When Siegfried learns of his delivery he tries on Sieglinde’s gown and it will likely be with him all through the opera. Lastly, Mime reveals Siegfried the 2 items of Nothung.

The Wanderer/Wotan arrives lined by a blanket and with an axe in a greatcoat with a wolf (!) pelt as its collar and he wields an axe. He’s again from a navy battle along with his backpack (the oxygen he wants is in it) and canine tag spherical his neck. His trembling arms possibly PTSD however all of that is underdeveloped. The Wanderer spends most of his time utilizing duct tape to affix all of the bits of his damaged spear collectively. Siegfried returns to make Nothung new once more however there isn’t any bellows, no hearth, and no anvil. Siegfried simply rubs the 2 items of the sword collectively, bangs the automobile door, then a bucket and his bandaged head. In the meantime Mime concocts one thing with a syringe and a few powdered medication. Deleted from my Walküre evaluation was how Siegmund’s wound appeared as important as that of Tristan or Amfortas and certainly Siegfried now pulls Nothung out from himself and makes use of it to chop off the tip of a fir tree.

On the opening on Act II a bloodied and bruised Alberich (isn’t everybody bloodied and bruised on this Ring?) arrives in a inexperienced sou’wester pulling a cart. He kidnaps a zombie-like android who’s clearly pregnant. As he confronts Wotan he makes use of forceps – beneath the quilt of a blanket – to ship child Hagen and makes use of a knife to chop the extravagant umbilical twine. We’re made conscious who in the end could inherit the ring. Wotan imitates the dragon when – along with Alberich – they try and warn him about Siegfried and on leaving hecovers the now useless android. On arrival Siegfried smears mud on himself for some motive and engages in some up to date dance as he responds to the Woodbird (there isn’t any reed and no horn).

The dragon – surrounded by extra orange-red smoke – is a huge model of the masks seen in Rheingold hooked up to an aerial ladder (or comparable) and with gentle shining via its eyes. Fafner himself is seen in scaly black-and-white with a panda’s (?) head and rows of big pearls round his neck. Siegfried withdraws the massive ring and a cape-like Tarnhelm from the face’s mouth and will get lined in blood and might be till the top of the opera. From then on Siegfried by no means appears to know what to do with the ring or Tarnhelm that he would possibly or may not have, or maybe comes into the motion with out both. After dispatching Mime, Siegfried as a personality (and singer?) seems completely spent whereas the crimson-haired Woodbird with sun shades and in yellow places in a short look ‘flying’ in on excessive.

After we see much more branches hanging down at first of the ultimate act Wotan summons Erda to what seems like supper at a desk within the woods. Erda is sporting a black negligee and brings in a big pan of soup, however their cosy meal doesn’t go nicely, and Wotan finally ends up threatening her. As a now-bloodier-than-ever Siegfried squares as much as Wotan, Erda watches on lined by a tablecloth typically laughing, typically grimacing. Siegfried hides beneath the desk, performs round with it, and throw a chair over, with Wotan getting the saucepan on his head prior to now powerless he crawls away twitching on the ground. The spear isn’t damaged once more, and Siegfried has it till it’s simply forged apart.

Maybe anticipating the stagehands’ strike Siegfried begins clearing the stage together with a few of the faux grass and briefly resists the pull of the ring. We quickly realise Brünnhilde (in black as in Walküre) has been cryogenically frozen above and Siegfried symbolically hacks at a block of ice for the ‘Das ist kein Mann!’ second. He ascends the steps to the frosted Brünnhilde earlier than awkwardly ripping down some polythene overlaying the opening on the entrance and cuddles her to heat her up for ‘Heil dir, Sonne! Heil dir, Licht!’ After all, there was no protect, helmet or breastplate. Ultimately down under Siegfried wrestles Brünnhilde to the bottom earlier than in an act of joint submission Brünnhilde removes her leather-based wristbands and Siegfried some bandages on his wrists. Siegfried used his bloody shirt to assist heat Brünnhilde and now it binds his wrists till minimize by Nothung. The ultimate duet has them at both finish of the sword earlier than lastly they embrace and stroll away.

I get uninterested in seeing and listening to Andreas Schager so typically in outstanding Wagner roles, is there nobody else price giving an opportunity to? To his credit score he’s a wholehearted performer as soon as once more as Siegfried and clearly embraces Bieito’s Personenregie uncomplainingly. His is a really offended, unlikable Siegfried with few redeeming options. As for his singing it was very effortful – uncomfortable at instances to the ear and eye – throughout essentially the most demanding moments of Act I which he appears to need to recover from as rapidly as doable. That he can sing extra quietly and lyrically was heard through the Forest Murmurs in Act II and it was a few of the finest singing I’ve heard from him in fairly some time. Nonetheless, in Act III he was vocally ‘operating on fumes’ and ended the duet with the bottom observe I can keep in mind from a Siegfried. I believe he will get applauded for all his Duracell bunny-like hyperactivity on the stage and the actual fact audiences have forgotten how the function needs to be sung.

This Ring has proved a triumph for Christopher Maltman as Wotan and marked by detailed performing (and reacting) that charts a transparent trajectory of declining authority. Maltman allies his sonorous baritone to Lieder-like phrasing in the same option to the good Michael Volle whose successor he appears to be as this technology’s main Wotan. The veteran Gerhard Siegel is a consummate character actor and Mime was neurotic, drug-addled and duplicitous; while at instances, oddly, extra nice to take heed to than Schager. Brian Mulligan portrayed a really anxious, scheming, and spiteful Alberich with a voice maybe extra suited to Wotan (which he additionally sings) than the malicious black dwarf.

There’s drowsiness, defiance and resignation from Erda’s involvement in Siegfried which we didn’t notably get from Marie-Nicole Lemieux who has a a lot lighter sound than a few of her predecessors within the function. Mika Kares had the perfect booming cavernousness bass for Fafner, both on or off the stage, and Ilanah Lobel-Torres was a sweetly chirruping Woodbird.

Lastly, I started to grasp that Tamara Wilson would possibly show an absolute revelation as Brünnhilde on this Ring if not for her performing however for the benefit, subtlety and radiance of her sound; regardless that her timbre isn’t notably youthful.

Pablo Heras-Casado – supported by an orchestra enjoying with compete fluency – carried out a suitably scherzo-like Siegfried with consummate pacing and a dramatic arc to meld all its shifting moods — Mime’s scheming, forging of Nothung, Fafner’s lair, Forest Murmurs and a last awakening of Brünnhilde — to not make it sound too episodic.

Will Götterdämmerung tie up Bieito’s myriad free ends or will we be left questioning – fairly like Parsifal – what it was we had seen.

Jim Pritchard

Featured Picture: Andreas Schager (Siegfried) and Gerhard Siegel (Mime) © Herwig Prammer/OnP

Creatives:
Staging – Calixto Bieito
Units – Rebecca Ringst
Costumes – Ingo Krügler
Designer – Maurice Mbikayi (masks of Heterotopia/Fafner’s costume)
Visible Artist – Zikun Zhu (Woodbird’s costume)
Lighting – Michael Bauer
Video – Sarah Derendinger
Dramaturgy – Bettina Auer

Solid:
Siegfried – Andreas Schager
Mime – Gerhard Siegel
The Wanderer – Christopher Maltman
Alberich – Brian Mulligan
Fafner – Mika Kares
Erda – Marie-Nicole Lemieux
Brünnhilde – Tamara Wilson
Voice of the Wooden hen – Ilanah Lobel-Torres

Related Articles

Latest Articles