![]() |
| Handel: Rinaldo – Ellie Donald, Agustin Pennino – Royal Academy Opera (Photograph: Craig Fuller) |
Handel: Rinaldo: Agustin Pennino, Caroline Blair, Ellie Donald, Joel Robson, director: Julia Burbach, conductor: David Bates, Royal Academy Opera; Susie Sainsbury Theatre at Royal Academy of Music
Reviewed 18 March 2026
Handel’s first Italian opera for London, reshaped as a vivid and pacey two hours with actual Handelian star high quality from among the forged and a vibrantly pressing account of the rating.
Having set some robust librettos throughout his four-year keep in Italy, from 1706 to 1710, in works like Agrippina and Il trionfo del Tempo e del Disinganno, Handel’s first opera for London, Rinaldo, which premiered in 1711 on the Queen’s Theatre featured a far much less spectacular libretto. Utilizing a state of affairs created by impresario Aaron Hill, the work aimed for visible spectacle to assist showcase the theatre’s equipment. Handel’s method to the music was related and his re-use of present materials from his Italian interval has led some to remark that the work is nearer to a pasticcio, a ‘better of’ assemblage. However no matter we expect the work’s dramatic logic (or lack thereof), it’s undoubtedly full of fine issues.
This appears to have been the method of director Julia Burbach and musical director David Bates for the brand new manufacturing of Handel’s Rinaldo from Royal Academy Opera. Double forged, on Wednesday 18 March 2026 we caught Agustin Pennino as Rinaldo, Caroline Blair as Almirena, Ellie Donald as Armida, Joel Robson as Argante, Yihui Wang as Goffredo and Pavel Basov as Eustazio. Designs have been by Bettina John, lighting by Robert Worth and choreography by Cameron McMillan. The Royal Academy Sinfonia was within the pit.
![]() |
| Handel: Rinaldo – Agustin Pennino, Caroline Blair – Royal Academy Opera (Photograph: Craig Fuller) |
Burbach’s intention within the manufacturing appears to have been to create a viable dramatic framework for the nice numbers from the opera, giving the forged alternatives past a easy recital. There have been important cuts: the opening scene of Act Two, with the mermaids/sirens, was lower, the recitative was pared all the way down to the bone and lots of arias shorn of the B sections. The ensuing work, as offered, was a pacey and vivid two hours within the theatre (together with interval). Burbach’s state of affairs performed up the ‘boys personal’ nature of the unique (one thing Robert Carsen’s somewhat Harry Potter-ish college manufacturing at Glyndebourne introduced out).
Casting used Handel’s 1731 revisions for the function of Goffredo, making him a tenor somewhat than alto castrato, however each Almirena and Armida have been sopranos as within the authentic 1711 manufacturing. The function of Eustazio, which was eradicated in later revivals, was included, however he was sung by a baritone (one thing I imagine Handel by no means did) somewhat than alto castrato. The mermaids (sirens) and Christian magician have been completely eradicated.
The drama passed off in a plain white field and at the start of the overture we noticed the forged in abnormal avenue garments, giving the work a way of play-acting. The best way Burbach had among the characters ship their strains perched above the rear wall introduced a component of comedy, and all through there was a way that the comedian was near the floor. This got here to the fore within the ultimate act the place the intercutting of scenes introduced out a way of comedy; one thing that was performed up in Rinaldo’s nice ultimate aria. The inclusion of the character of Eustazio was not merely completed from a need to extend the variety of solo roles. Burbach had recast the character as a playful Cupid determine who concerned himself within the motion all through, thus eradicating the necessity for inner dramatic logic (which the piece somewhat lacks).
![]() |
| Handel: Rinaldo – Pavel Basov – Royal Academy Opera (Photograph: Craig Fuller) |
Agustin Pennino made an earnest and ardent Rinaldo. He entered with a will into the motion and sang with fantastic, vivid voice that supplied a beautiful accuracy within the passagework. Few emotional depths have been plumbed, however then the opera is not about that. Pennino moved confidently from the poignant ‘Cara sposa’ to a vivid ‘Venti, turbini, prestate’ and a ultimate ‘Or la tromba’ that was musically vivid despite the fact that the staging despatched the work up.
The opera affords little likelihood for intimate interplay between Rinaldo and Almirena, so Pennino and Caroline Blair have been remarkably correct of their interactions till the top of the opera. Blair made a neat, somewhat contained Almirena. Her chook aria in Act One, although fantastically exactly sung, was considerably overshadowed by some vivid flute and piccolo enjoying within the orchestra. Her method to ‘Lascia ch’io pianga’ was neat, correct and somewhat too contained in order that the vivid sounds from Bates and the orchestra somewhat dominated. It was solely in Act Three, when the plot unwound, that Blair appeared to let go and provides us a glimpse of the actual Almirena.
Ellie Donald made a really vivid Armida, although it was unlucky that her opening ‘Furie terribili!’ was somewhat upstaged by the crash of percussion within the orchestra. However Donald had nice enjoyable all through the opera actually vamping up the character. This was allied to a really fashionable manner with Handel’s music, although as but her method appeared a little bit too appropriate in order that musically Donald didn’t fairly match the vivid visuals, and I did marvel what she would have made from Almirena.
![]() |
| Handel: Rinaldo – Yihui Wang – Royal Academy Opera (Photograph: Craig Fuller) |
Joel Robson’s huge entrance aria as Argante, ‘Sibillar gli angui d’Aletto’ (which honestly has little to do with the drama past making a Large Entrance) was undercut by the truth that Robson needed to sing it descending backwards down a step-ladder. Robson made Argante a considerably shabby determine, not fairly the swaggering normal. This meant his wooing of Almirena in Act Two had a touching component, and we somewhat felt for him as he was woefully bullied by Donald’s Armida.
Yihui Wang was introduced as having been in poor health, however he nonetheless sang Goffredo with a pleasant swaggering confidence, although his efficiency type in Handel’s music appeared to somewhat lean extra in the direction of the nineteenth century. Pavel Basov made an enticing Eustazio/Cupid, producing fairly a little bit of cheeky appeal, although his voice didn’t appear naturally comfy with Handel and his earlier roles have been in operas by Tchaikovsky, Rimsky Korsakov, Mussorgsky and Verdi.
Within the pit, the 25 gamers of the Royal Academy Sinfonia introduced brilliance and color to a rating which has its share of showy moments. Missing the dazzling stage equipment of the unique, we have been capable of benefit from the vivid dazzle produced by the gamers. Bates’s method appeared to be somewhat interventionist, however his gamers went with it with a will, following his urging to create an pressing efficiency.
![]() |
| Handel: Rinaldo – Joel Robson, Ellie Donald – Royal Academy Opera (Photograph: Craig Fuller) |
Rinaldo was designed to bedazzle the viewers each with the stage results and with the virtuosic singing. Shorn of the previous, we needed to depend on the latter which is to a sure extent unfair on younger singers who’re new to Handelian type. However the forged entered into the idea with a will, and each Agustin Pennino and Ellie Donald confirmed the form of Handelian star high quality which instructed they’ll carry an opera seria.
The weblog is free, however I might be delighted if you happen to have been to indicate your appreciation by shopping for me a espresso.
Elsewhere on this weblog
- All-IN-4Art with Bettina Bermbach of Deutsche Stiftung Musikleben (DSM, the German Basis for Musical Life) – interview
- French fireworks & German heroes: David Butt Philip & Pals gala at St Paul’s Opera, Clapham – opera assessmentÂ
- Recollections of a County Kerry childhood & a travelling Scot: Stephen McNeff’s Ballads of a Bogman & RVW’s Songs of Journey at Wigmore Corridor for St Patrick’s Day – assessmentÂ
- Very important & participating: Handel’s early English masque, Acis & Galatea, & his setting of Dryden’s A Music for St Cecilia, reminiscent of concert events in 1739Â – assessment
- It takes two! Countertenor AgustÃn Pennino & mezzo-soprano Ella Orehek-Coddington on sharing the function of Rinaldo at Royal Academy Opera – interview
- Letter from Florida: Lisette Oropesa delivers fireworks at Palm Seashore Opera’s 2026 Gala – live performance assessmentÂ
- A lifetime of quiet business: songs by Ina Boyle, her academics & buddies from Ailish Tynan, Paula Murrihy, Robin Tritschler, Iain Burnside – assessment
- DwellingÂ
Â





